Back to topics

Embedded vs Server-Centric: MainyDB’s Mongo-like Python NoSQL and Rails UUIDv7 PKs

1 min read
248 words
Database Debates Embedded Server-Centric:

Two threads collide on the same day: embedded simplicity vs server-side guarantees. MainyDB brings MongoDB-style documents to a single-file store for Python, with PyMongo compatibility and offline operation. It even supports Mongo-like operators and aggregation pipelines in a true embedded fashion [1].

Embedded niche: MainyDB’s approach MainyDB stores data in a single .mdb file, no server required, and offers two syntax modes—its own Pythonic syntax or PyMongo compatibility [1]. It’s designed for offline prototyping, with thread-safe access and asynchronous writes, plus built-in binary/media handling via base64 [1].

  • Server model — MainyDB: No server; MongoDB: Yes; TinyDB: No; SQLite: No. [1]
  • Mongo syntax and pipelines — MainyDB: Yes; MongoDB: Yes; TinyDB: No; SQLite: No. [1]
  • Binary/media support — MainyDB: Built-in; MongoDB: Manual; TinyDB: No; SQLite: No. [1]

Rails UUIDv7 PKs: app-side vs DB-side On the Rails side, the UUIDv7 PK debate shows up in code that generates IDs in the app with SecureRandom.uuid_v7 before persistence. The approach means the ID is known prior to save, but bulk SQL inserts can bypass model hooks—letting the database generate PKs avoids that gap [2].

  • Rails productRuby on Rails app code uses an afterinitialize hook to create IDs via SecureRandom.uuidv7 [2].
  • PostgreSQL 18 — The post weighs the DB-side approach as a way to cover all inserts, especially bulk ones [2].

Taken together, embedded models win on simplicity and portability, while server-based stores lean into centralized guarantees and consistency—key decisions that shape performance and developer ergonomics.

References

[1]
HackerNews

Show HN: MainyDB – an embedded MongoDB-style database for Python

Introduces MainyDB, a single-file embedded Python NoSQL with Mongo-like queries and PyMongo compatibility, compares to MongoDB/TinyDB/SQLite, seeks feedback.

View source
[2]
HackerNews

Using UUIDv7 with Ruby on Rails Without PostgreSQL 18

Discusses using UUIDv7 for primary keys in Rails, PostgreSQL involvement, and app-side vs DB-side generation tradeoffs.

View source

Want to track your own topics?

Create custom trackers and get AI-powered insights from social discussions

Get Started