Pricing Debates and Update Commitments: One-Time Purchases vs Subscriptions in the Mac/iOS App World

Pricing debates in the Mac app world are back in force. The core question: should you ride SetApp-style subscriptions, or buy licenses one by one? A pair of Reddit threads sum up the tension: “Is SetApp worth the subscription fee?” ^[1] and “For those who don’t mind paying one time for apps, do you expect the developers to update the apps forever to run on future macOS versions?” ^[2].

Pricing models and SetApp value: SetApp offers a library for a recurring price, but buyers worry you never own the apps and the service could change or disappear ^[1]. If you do buy, a museum of popular one-time licenses exists, including BetterTouchTool, ForkLift, DevTools, CleanShot X, Downie, iStat Menus, Dropshare, Soulver, TextSniper, and Permute ^[1]. Some folks insist ownership matters and that licenses beat the risk of a changing catalog ^[1].

Users also chase post-SetApp update helpers after Mac updater’s shutdown. Some switched to Updatest ^[1], while others mention Latest and Macupdater as alternatives as the ecosystem shifts ^[1].

Indefinite updates debate: In the other thread, folks push back on perpetual updates for ongoing payments. One says, “I buy the app for what it does now, not what it might do in the future” ^[2], while another warns against being locked behind future payments or “monthly ransom” ^[2]. The sentiment echoes comparisons to Adobe licenses, where past perpetual purchases diverge from subscription-only models, and even calls out GoodNotes as a cautionary example ^[2].

Closing thought: Pricing models will keep evolving with OS timelines and how much users value owning software versus ongoing access.

References